Temptations Surfer's Delight Cat Treats Review: Worth It?

Quick Verdict

The Temptations Surfer's Delight cat treats earn their reputation as a reliable, vet-approved snack that most cats genuinely love. The triple seafood punch — tuna, shrimp, and salmon — hits a flavor profile that even the pickiest felines struggle to ignore. At under 2 calories per treat, it strikes a sensible balance between indulgence and responsible snacking. If you're after a daily reward your cat will actually work for, this tub is a solid pick. Score: 4.3/5

What Is the Temptations Surfer's Delight Cat Treats?

Let's get the basics down. The Temptations Surfer's Delight MixUps is a 16-ounce resealable tub filled with bite-sized cat treats that blend three seafood flavors — tuna, shrimp, and salmon — into one crunchy-outside, soft-inside morsel. It's part of the well-established Temptations brand from Mars Petcare, which has been making cat treats for decades and is one of the most recognizable names on the treat aisle.

The Surfer's Delight variety specifically leans into the ocean-to-plate appeal, marketing itself as a "trifecta" of seafood flavors that cats supposedly can't resist. The texture is genuinely noteworthy: the shell gives a satisfying crunch, but there's a softer center that melts slightly on contact with saliva. Cats seem to enjoy both phases of the eating experience. The tub is resealable, which sounds like a minor detail until you've dealt with stale, dried-out treats from a poorly sealed bag.

Key Features

• Triple seafood flavor: tuna, shrimp, and salmon in every bite
• Crunchy shell with a soft interior for dual-texture satisfaction
• Under 2 calories per treat — ideal for frequent rewarding
• 16 oz resealable tub keeps treats fresh between sessions
• Shake-to-serve design appeals to cats' auditory food triggers
• Suitable for adult cats and kittens over 8 weeks
• Made by Temptations, a vet-recommended cat treat brand

Hands-On Review

I cracked open the Surfer's Delight tub on a lazy Saturday afternoon. The moment I twisted the lid, my older cat — a somewhat indifferent 7-year-old tabby named Milo — appeared in the kitchen doorway. No joke. The smell traveled. Within seconds, both cats were circling my ankles, which, for a cat who's normally too dignified to beg, was telling.

I started with a handful as a post-lunch reward. The treats dispensed easily from the tub, and the resealable lid snapped shut with a satisfying click — not that I trust it completely with a determined paw, but it's held up for three weeks now without any air leaking in. What surprised me was the smell. It's genuinely pungent. If you're sensitive to fish odors or keep treats near your own food storage, this might bother you. The aroma lingered in my pantry even after I moved the tub to a closed cabinet.

Over the following two weeks, I used these as training treats for basic recall and a couple of trick sessions. The low calorie count meant I could give 15-20 per session without feeling guilty. Milo earned them for sitting; my younger cat, Luna, couldn't distinguish between earning treats and just existing near the tub, which... says something about the flavor power. By day five, just shaking the bag prompted visible anticipation.

Texture-wise, the crunch holds up even after the tub has been opened for a couple of weeks. Some softer treats go stale quickly after exposure to air, but these maintained their bite. The soft center isn't mushy — it's more like a slightly tender inner layer that gives way under back teeth. Cats don't analyze texture, of course, but the behavioral evidence (no half-chewed casualties left on the floor) suggests the texture works.

The only real hesitation I had: Luna, my senior, started demanding treats more aggressively around day ten. She developed a specific yowl. That's not the treat's fault, but it's worth noting if you have a cat prone to behavioral food fixation. More treats didn't fix it; resetting her expectations did.

Who Should Buy It?

• Cat owners using treats for training — the low calorie count and strong aroma make these effective for repeated rewarding without overfeeding.
• Multi-cat households — the large 16 oz tub offers better value than smaller bags and the resealable lid handles frequent opening.
• Seafood-loving cats — if your feline goes wild for fish flavors, the triple seafood combo is genuinely appealing.
• Daily reward givers — if you like to give your cat a treat as part of their routine, under 2 calories per piece keeps it reasonable.

Skip this if: your cat has a known seafood allergy, you're extremely sensitive to fish odors in your home, or you prefer treats with fully transparent sourcing and minimal ingredient lists. Also, if your cat already has food-aggression issues, the intensity of the aroma might exacerbate problem behaviors.

Alternatives Worth Considering

• Greenies Salmon Flavor Cat Treats — a similar crunchy-soft texture with a single protein focus. Better if you want a simpler ingredient profile and dental-health claims.
• Blue Buffalo Wilderness Trail Treats — grain-free option with real meat as the first ingredient. Better for cats on limited-ingredient diets, though they're pricier per ounce.
• Purina Friskies Party Mix — budget-friendly alternative with multiple textures and flavors. Not as premium, but solid for households watching costs closely.

FAQ

Final Verdict

The Temptations Surfer's Delight cat treats deliver exactly what they promise: a triple seafood flavor that cats find irresistible, packaged in a convenient resealable tub at a reasonable price point. The under-2-calorie count makes daily use practical for most cats, and the crunchy-soft texture genuinely satisfies. It's not a gourmet treat with single-source ingredients, but it's not trying to be. What it is: a reliable, vet-recognized training and reward treat that earns its place on the shelf. My cats approved. Yours probably will too.