Temptations Creamy Puree Cat Treats Review: A Vet's Honest Verdict

Quick Verdict

I've been using the Temptations Creamy Puree cat treats for about two weeks across three cats — a spry two-year-old, a cautious five-year-old, and a twelve-year-old with missing teeth. The verdict? These squeezable lickable treats deliver on their core promise: cats genuinely love them. The puree texture worked flawlessly for the senior cat who struggled with anything requiring actual chewing. At under 15 calories per tube, guilt-free treating is actually doable. I'd rate these 4.5 out of 5 — not perfect, but close enough for regular use.

What Are the Temptations Creamy Puree Cat Treats?

Temptations Creamy Puree cat treats are squeezable wet treats that come in small 0.42 oz tubes — think of them as a go-gurt for cats. You squeeze the puree directly into a dish, onto your finger, or over your cat's regular food as a topper. The 24-count variety pack I tested includes chicken, salmon, and tuna flavors, though individual tubes aren't labeled, so you can't pick and choose which flavor goes to which cat.

What sets these apart from standard crunchy treats is the texture: a smooth, lickable puree that requires zero chewing. That makes them genuinely useful for senior cats, kittens still learning to eat solids, or any cat dealing with dental discomfort. The brand — Temptations — is owned by Mars Petcare, so you've got the backing of a major pet food manufacturer behind the formula.

Key Features

• Under 15 calories per 0.42 oz tube for guilt-free treating
• Smooth puree texture — no chewing required
• Three flavors in one box: chicken, salmon, tuna
• Three feeding methods: by hand, in a dish, or as meal topper
• No added sugar, fillers, or artificial preservatives
• Single-serve packaging — no measuring or mess
• Suitable for senior cats and those with dental sensitivities

Hands-On Review

My Maine Coon mix, Luna, ignored the first tube for almost thirty seconds — unusual for her. Then she dove in face-first. Within seconds her chin was covered in salmon-chicken goodness, and she was making that specific "mrrow" sound that means more. I tried the same tube on my elderly tabby, Beans, who has exactly four teeth left. He couldn't manageCrunch treats anymore, but the puree? He finished the entire tube in under a minute with zero struggle.

What surprised me was the smell. Look, I'm a cat owner — I've smelled worse. But these have a distinctly fishy, umami punch that lingers. The kitchen smelled like tuna for about twenty minutes after treat time. If you're sensitive to food odors, keep that in mind.

Using them as a meal topper was the real test. I sprinkled half a tube over Beans's dry kibble one morning. He ate everything, including the kibble he'd been leaving half-finished for weeks. The moisture in the puree softened the crunchies slightly, which seemed to help. That alone might justify keeping a box in the pantry.

One thing nobody mentions in the listings: the tubes are slightly awkward to hold if your hands are wet or covered in gloop. I ended up using my non-dominant hand to steady the tube while squeezing — a minor ergonomic complaint, but worth noting if you're dealing with arthritic hands yourself.

Who Should Buy It?

The obvious fit is anyone with a senior cat or a cat recovering from dental work. The lickable texture genuinely solves a problem that crunchy treats can't.

• Senior cat owners: If your older cat has trouble with regular treats or dry food, these are a practical solution — not a gimmick.
• Multi-cat households: The variety pack keeps things interesting, and at under 15 calories each, treating multiple cats doesn't add up to much.
• Meal topper seekers: Cats who are finicky about dry kibble may eat more when a puree is involved.
• Bonding-focused owners: Feeding by hand creates a nice interactive moment — it's not just about the calories.

Skip this if your cat has a known fish allergy — the variety pack doesn't let you isolate the chicken-only option. Also skip if you're strongly opposed to single-use plastic tubes, since each treat generates its own small waste footprint.

Alternatives Worth Considering

If the Temptations Creamy Puree cat treats don't quite fit your needs, here are a couple of alternatives worth comparing:

• Churu Cat Treats: Also squeezable and lickable, with a slightly thicker consistency. More flavor options available, but typically sold in multi-packs without variety. Good if you want a single flavor.
• Inaba Churu Grain-Free Cat Treats: A closer cousin to the Temptations option but with a wider ingredient list that includes more real meat. Slightly pricier per tube.
• Greenies Feline Dental Treats: The opposite approach — crunchy treats designed for dental health. Better for cats without dental issues, but won't help senior cats who can't chew.

FAQ

Final Verdict

The Temptations Creamy Puree cat treats do exactly what they say on the box. They're low-calorie, the cats go wild for them, and the puree format genuinely helps cats who can't handle crunchy snacks. The variety pack is convenient, and using them as a meal topper is a legitimate strategy for picky eaters or senior cats.

They're not without minor flaws — the smell is aggressive, the packaging generates waste, and the lack of flavor labeling in the variety pack is a small frustration. But these are quibbles, not dealbreakers. Will I keep buying them? Yes, especially for Beans. His quality of life improved measurably once he could enjoy treat time again without pain.